+27 83 629-7690
The Green Faith

The Green Faith

By Roy Kloet. (From: Het Zoeklicht)

Recently, the University of Helsinki decided to give Greta Thunberg an honorary doctorate. This is the highest university award. With the help of her famous mother (1), she drew worldwide attention to climate change. From the age of 15, she ‘went on strike’ weekly at the Swedish parliament for the climate. Greta was highly appreciated for her climate activism. In 2019, Time Magazine named her “Person of the Year” and she won the Children’s Peace Award. She was even nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize.

“By choosing Greta as an honorary doctor, we express our desire to be as courageous and impactful as she is,” says professor Nissinen.

A school drop-out without any scientific achievements is thus bestowed with academic greatness. It perhaps says more about the state of science. But no matter how we feel about it, Greta is successful in her earthly struggle. Concerned people see her as a figurehead; a voice in the desert to keep the earth habitable.

A striking detail: Greta receives her honorary doctorate in Theology (2). Historian Bouwman frowns: “Guilt, penance, the end of time, denunciation of unbelievers and now also a theological honorary doctorate for the ‘holy virgin’. For those who still doubted whether green is a religion.” The former leaders of the German Evangelical Church and the Anglican Church of England compared Greta to Jeremiah. The Catholic Bishop Koch called her a modern prophet.

THE RISE OF THE CLIMATE RELIGION

Just because Greta isn’t a Christian theologian doesn’t mean she is not religious. This climate apostle is a follower of a radical religion that fits precisely with the spirit of the time. Many have left God and are seeking a surrogate faith to fill the void. The climate religion gives people the feeling of living for something bigger than their own little ego island. Standing up for the planet, for mother earth. Well, OK, you may also call it “creation”.

Thus, “green” really became an alternative belief of some sort for some. This is not only evidenced by Greta’s appointment as a top theologian. Worldwide we see religious traits everywhere around climate and greenery. Many who left the church are now becoming fanatical supporters of climate science. They willingly sacrifice to the green idol, Mother Earth. And everyone has to participate! The pagans now worship their nature gods again, their golden calf is now green. We must repent because enemies threaten the planet.

A minuscule amount of Nitrogen Oxide precipitates, more details here:

https://breadonthewater.co.za/2023/04/17/bullying-of-the-farmers/

or a little bit more of the Carbon Dioxide (CO2) flies around our ears, details here:

Henry’s Climate | Bread on the water

Climate science is given an unassailable, almost sacred status. The “inconvenient truth” is that we are all climate sinners. The mainstream media blows the trumpet almost daily and has put it high on the agenda. Time and again there is a stage for the prophets and followers of the Extinction Rebellion and like-minded people. Ecology is the in-thing. More and more people who fight for climate justice, are willing to sacrifice and step out of their comfort zone and block the highways. Some glue themselves on the asphalt. A few glue themselves to a Vermeer canvas. Or rant against a Van Gogh with tomato soup. The media love it. From children’s TV programs to the weather reports, the message is repeated over and over again that we have to change. Everything that is wrong in the world is now due to the climate crisis. When we get to +1.5 degrees, it’s too late. We may still be able to save the planet, if we all repent and minimize our emissions. Some go so far in their crusade for a smaller carbon footprint that they no longer want to give birth: the birth strikers. Every child that is born less, saves 58.6 tons of CO2 emissions per year. For such a saving, you have to stop 24 cars for a year. Or 73 people should become vegetarians.

Those who do not participate are ignored or denounced. Unwelcome messages simply disappear from the internet, as do climate prophecies that never came true (3). A former director of the Dutch media organization cannot express his opinions because the editor-in-chief (NOS) does not like it. All ‘climate deniers’ are now being silenced. This also happens when you doubt not so much anything about climate change, but perhaps just the amount of human contribution to it, or the draconian measures to minimize emissions. There is apparently no separation of state here. United, even beyond their primary remit, governments, banks, regulators and multinationals preach the climate message. Anyone who sees a threat in this unity can now be classified as a threat by the secret service because of ‘anti-institutional extremism’.

THE CLIMATE CHURCH

Mother Earth is a wrathful type of goddess, and fear and despair reign among many climate believers. That even leads to climate depressions. A humanistic alliance has already set up discussion groups for people with climate burnout or climate depression.

You would think that this would offer Christians a great opportunity to bring the hopeful gospel of Christ. For He is the Savior of sinful man and of a Creation that sighs (Romans ch. 8). But surprise, surprise: many churches no longer expect Him, and they certainly no longer expect anything from Him.

Believing in green is hip. Christians feel called to prevent global warming themselves. “As good stewards, we should shepherd the planet and build God’s Kingdom,” some argue. It is indeed important to have an eye for God’s original plan for man and all of His creation. To take care of it and enjoy it. But when we simply ignore the Creator and think we can restore this creation ourselves, pride and self-justification lurk around the corner. No matter how well-intentioned, we cannot be the savior. Where this is taught, churches are changed and Christianity is redefined. Then one proclaims another gospel. That’s the “Kingdom Now,” eco-gospel.  (4)

Various Christian organizations work with churches on sustainability and greening (5). These can be good initiatives. Few people will reject the correct sustainable handling of resources. If the world went down tomorrow, Luther would plant an apple tree today. But you are on slippery ice when, for example, the planting of that tree becomes the core of the preaching. And what do we see: ‘Green churches’ together with the (Dutch) media organize ‘a real sermon competition for theologians and non-theologians on a theme around climate and sustainability‘. A worship service for creation? Are we not going to “worship and serve the creation above the Creator”? (Rom. 1:25, Matt. 4:10). Things really become problematic when not Christ, but only the green faith is proclaimed:

  1. There are already: ‘a green pastor, green patriarch, green pope and green liturgies for lamentation, sorrow and mourning’
  2. They advocate for real climate conversion. In the confession of climate sins one finds healing, liberation and tranquility.
  3. There is already a ‘vigil for creation’ 
  4. Green theology advocates a “reinvention of Christianity.”
  5. Breaking the laws for climate protests are encouraged.

EXTREME GREEN

Prominent Christians are committed to Extinction Rebellion (XR) or its Christian counterpart Christian Climate Action (CCA). Sometimes Christian activists go to a demonstration or blockade in preachers’ toga. To ‘rebel for life’ by blocking the roads. XR and CCA don’t accept half-work or “cheap grace”.  Climate justice now! Many people feel  ‘a lot of camaraderie in the climate movement’.  I like to believe that. But if you experience more comradeship (6) with XR than with fellow Christians in the church, aren’t you in danger of standing in the path of the sinners?  Or to sit there, in a circle of people that curse God or use foul language?

Knowingly breaking the law and then ending up in jail makes you frown? I quote a lady pastor who works for various organizations: “From my ministry, I feel that I cannot remain silent. Arrest is also sometimes the goal. Then it’s a shame if you don’t get arrested because that’s what makes the media. For me, blocking the road is a form of love to ‘God’. In no other place do I feel so close to God as after an arrest.” To add, “Paul ended up in prison, didn’t he?”

Yes. Yes. But not with a message on climate and blocking the roads!  In Acts (25:8), he even advocates the opposite. Although Paul lived in a Roman world full of slavery and injustice, the core of his preaching was Christ (1 Corinthians 15:3-4). Paul ended up in jail because he was talking about Jesus! Proclaiming a half-biblical truth for a biased climate purpose is a fallacy. Paul is extraordinarily sharp in his rejection of errant doctrine.

“If we take the Bible seriously, we would be at the front of the queue to force climate action!” says climate scientist Hayhoe. (7)

No. No. And again, no. If people are dying today, they need the Gospel now. The Gospel is free. God himself has paid ALL the debt for us. And He has promised a new creation. If you happen to have a green heart, and you can reach people who are desperate about the climate, then above all, proclaim to them the liberating Gospel of Christ!

CONCLUSION

The church of Jesus Christ is not on earth to promote sustainability. Nowhere in the Bible does it say that we must or can save the world (8). He is the Lord and He is also Lord of the Weather! (Matt. 8:23-27). Many exploit the earth to serve mammon (money). Do not serve mammon, nor creation. God is in us, part of us, and nothing escapes Him. Fight the good fight. Help those who are struggling (Matt. 25:31-46) and worship the Creator above the creature. That is the Law and the Prophets. Proclaim hope and do not despair. He is with us, in the same boat.

The Lord is coming back!

References:

  1. Malena Emman represented Sweden in the Eurovision Song Contest (2009) and was environmental hero of the Swedish World Wildlife Fund (2017).
  2. The study of God, faith, rituals and religious scriptures.
  3. For example, there would be no permanent ice at the North Pole in 2022.
  4. In 2022, interfaith leaders presented the “Ten Commandments for Climate Justice.”
  5. e.g, Micha Nederland, A Rocha, GroeneKerken, Laudata Si’alliantie, Missie Nederland and Tearfund.
  6. A striking (communistic) type of word choice!
  7. See website CCA. Or: ‘No flood after us’. (That’s right. The end of the world is different…)
  8. We must proclaim the coming Kingdom of God, but we do not have to build it. (Note Jesus’ summary of the Law and the Prophets, Matt. 22:37-40) 

Roy Kloet

Bullying of the farmers

Bullying of the farmers

The farmers in the Netherlands are being bullied by the government and the media into stopping with farming and selling out due to their emission of ammonia and NOx. I wrote something on the Dutch blog about this and perhaps there are some of you here who are interested to see as to how the ‘climate crisis’  (nitrogen) is being used to try and disown the farmers there.

Please click on the link:

https://www.climategate.nl/2023/04/boeren-pesten/

Obviously, it is written in Dutch but there is a translate button in the lefthand corner, where you can choose to read it in US English. This story is just unbelievable, is it not? It is like chopping off the hands that give you food. For the benefit of interested parties in Belgium and the Netherlands I have written a follow up:

Boeren pesten – Climategate Klimaatwritten a follow -up (not yet translated)

If there is anyone here who can follow the science that I spelled out in the above article, you will notice that there really is no ‘nitrogen’ problem at all in Belgium and the Netherlands. The question therefore becomes: what is the reason for this bullying? Where is this going to lead?

Take some time to watch the video, here:

Best Easter Sermon!

Take the time to watch the sermon, it starts at around 48 minutes into the service or watch the whole service which starts in 2 minutes from the beginning! I am sure you will be blessed as I was. If an advert appears in the screen, just remove it by clicking on the x.  

Letter to minister Dr. K.D. Ramokgopa

Could you please forward this message to our minister of electricity, Dr. K.D. Ramokgopa. Thank you.

Dear Dr. Ramokgopa

First of all, my congratulations on your appointment as minister! I wish you God’s richest blessings on your work.

I am a retired chemist and I would like to help you find a quick solution to our energy crisis. I have a college diploma in chemistry and a diploma in Datametrics as well as and many years of experience in the field of data analyses. As a hobby, during my retirement, I looked at some data on climate change. My findings on climate change in South Africa are reported in detail here:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/tps2cd4kuds8o6g/SUBMISSION%20by%20Henry%20Pool.docx?dl=0

Sadly, I did not receive any reply on my submission from the relevant department. I thought that was rather impolite? Fact is, that I could not really find any significant climate change in South Africa over the past 40 years. As far as global warming is concerned, I also found some rather inconvenient truths:

https://breadonthewater.co.za/2021/11/25/an-inconvenient-truth/ 

The above was to just give you some background about me and what I think of the so-called ‘man-made climate crisis’. 

Now, some people, apparently Mr. DeRuyter amongst them, seem to think that we can simply solve our energy crisis with ‘renewables’ like wind and sun.

Unfortunately, it is not so easy; generating electricity is far more difficult than people realize. Coal power stations are huge; you can park a couple of Boeings inside one, easily. But the public wants a quick-fix to an electricity shortage so they jump at apparent solutions, such as solar panels and wind turbines. These renewable energy devices are not equal to a huge coal power station, not by any stretch of the imagination. There is also the added problem that solar is only available for part of the day, and not at all at night. Wind is only available when the wind blows, and you don’t know when that will be. That means that with this type of renewable energy, you still need decent back-up. I am sure that you will agree with me that we simply do not have the luxury for this in South-Africa.

On the issue of using coal (1) for energy I am neutral. However, although carbon-dioxide is not a poison, we know that Sulphur and sulphureous compounds are very poisonous as they can interfere with our breathing. This therefore has to be removed from the exhaust when you burn coal. I understand that they want to scrap the old coal power stations where this is not being done, and where it is not feasible to modify with Sulphur sweeping. My recommendation is not to scrap any of the old coal-fired power stations but to rather re-fit them to run on gas. Apparently, there is a gas pipe running from Mozambique to Sasolburg and it cuts right through the areas where these coal-fired power stations are situated.

 

Note that gas (2) burns clean and there is no Sulphur so it does not need any Sulphur removal. Also, if you do the calculations, there is a saving of 50% in the emission of CO2 per kWh generated. If you want me to, I can look up the official reports on that. Fact is that with gas as fuel there is a saving of 50% in carbon emission when compared to coal. Note that a country such as The Netherlands, who already have much wind and solar, they still need gas-fired power stations as a back-up.

 

However, if you would prefer to go 100%  carbon-free,  you should clearly consider the nuclear (3) option. Actually, we are fortunate in South-Africa that a lot of work has already been done on smaller nuclear reactors, like the Pebble Bed Nuclear reactors. The latest development, the HTMR-100 does not need water cooling as it is gas cooled with Helium. My thinking is that they could also be placed in, at or near the old coal-fired power stations so that you can still use the existing network for the distribution of power.

If money is a problem, I can also help you by giving you an idea on how to raise money for such a project:

 

Let’s go nuclear! | Bread on the water

 

Dr. Ramokgoda, I hope that you will take note of this letter and that perhaps I will hear from you?

Best wishes,

 

 

Henry Pool 

Cel. 0836297690

https://breadonthewater.co.za/blog/

Cel. +27 (0)836297690

henrypool7@gmail.com

 

Let’s go nuclear!

Let’s go nuclear!

The other day I read a post written by Dr. Kelvin Klemm from Stratek Global (Pty) Ltd. It starts off like this:

‘Electricity is the lifeblood of the country. If it stops flowing, the economy immediately starts to decay. The average citizen notices it immediately when the electricity stops flowing, because the kettle does not work, and the lights go out. Oviously there is an instant public reaction.

The public demands ‘a solution’. So people look for a ‘quick-fix’.

Unfortunately, it is not so easy; generating electricity is far more difficult than people realize. Coal power stations are huge; you can park a couple of Boeings inside one, easily. But the public wants a quick-fix to an electricity shortage so they jump at apparent solutions, such as solar panels and wind turbines. These renewable energy devices are not equal to a huge coal power station, not by any stretch of the imagination. There is also the added problem that solar is only available for part of the day, and not at all at night. Wind is only available when the wind blows, and you don’t know when that will be.

Imagine that you have just undergone open heart surgery and you’re in the Intensive Care Unit; ask yourself; would you rather have the Intensive Care Unit attached to solar and wind power, or rather attached to coal or nuclear power? If you are a miner working two or three kilometers underground in an inherently hot, dusty gold mine, that same question is most important too!’ 

The current energy crisis is a huge problem and if we do not solve it soon, it will lead us into all kinds of other problems, in all kinds of fields, from healthcare to agriculture. Who wants to get operated on in a hospital when the power fails?  Obviously, you can expect rising food production costs because the farmer now has to irrigate his land with pumps connected to diesel generators. This diesel is currently very expensive. And so the list goes on and on of more and more industries seeking exemption from load-shedding. But that puts a bigger burden on other industries. The end result will be rising inflation and more and more poverty. 

I did already propose one solution for the crisis, namely, instead of scrapping the old coal-fired power stations that do not have the sulfur swiping ability that is required, they could be re-furnished to run on gas, see here:

North, south, east, west: Gas best! | Bread on the water

Truly, it seems the only other option that we have is clean nuclear energy. South Africa built the Koeberg nuclear power station to supply electricity from the South ‘upwards’ to complement the coal-supplied electricity coming from the North ‘downwards’, but there is still a huge space in-between which includes points of high electricity consumption such as large mining complexes and major manufacturing centres.

So in 1993 a decision was made to start investigating the potential in developing a Small Modular Reactor (SMR) to be placed in South African areas in which there were no major supplies of water. South Africa has minimal spare inland water. So South Africa became the first country in the world to start designing a commercial Pebble Bed Modular Reactor (PBMR). The project grew to a significant size, with a total workforce of some 2,000 people, and by 2008 the reactor was ready to be built. The pressure vessel was ordered and it arrived in South Africa.

But 2008 was an ominous year.

That was the year of the great US-induced international financial meltdown when major US banks went bankrupt, and it was only a few months later in the following year that South Africa had an abrupt change of government. Those factors, and a few others, led to the PBMR project to be put into a ‘Pause mode’ not long after, from which it never emerged. Anti-nuclear propaganda worldwide was also in full swing, which very much influenced decisions.

The HTMR-100 Emerges

What positive action did happen as a result of the PBMR programme is that a group of engineers and scientists from the PBMR project started their own project to design a cheaper, simpler, and faster-to-build reactor as a derivative of the PBMR.

It was called the HTMR-100. See picture below and at the beginning of this post. Below the red line is underground. Over the following number of years the HTMR-100 was designed to the point at which it has been ready to build since 2020. The HTMR-100 is privately owned but requires significant funding to move into construction of the First Of A Kind (FOAK) model. The beauty of this SMR is that is does not need cooling water. It is a gas cooled nuclear reactor. That means it could easily be placed in, at or near coal fired power stations that need to be scrapped because of their lack of proper sulfur removal ability. That way you could still use the infra structure that is available there to distribute the electricity.

A few African leaders have made powerful public statements about their intention to take their countries on a nuclear path. It is possible, by using Small Modular reactors which do not need large scale water cooling. African countries can also easily form a collaborative ‘club’ to link to each other with daily operations, training, and regulatory oversight, amongst other functions. Such an approach will lower costs further and also induce a spirit of cooperation which will be beneficial to all.

Advanced countries have also shown great interest in SMR systems to use in specific applications, or for smaller areas such as municipalities, or specific industrial applications.

The HTMR-100 is now ready to be build. Compared to coal and patrol which only produce 24 and 46 mega Joules per kg, respectively, Uranium gives us 76 million mega Joules per kg! The enriched fuel is produced in South Africa.

Investors just need to have the confidence in an advanced energy solution development coming from Africa. Some established mindsets need to change. The SMR from South Africa is an investment opportunity waiting for people with vision, and some courage, and who also have self-confidence, and a belief in abundant and reliable green power for the future. I even think that in the end, our current discomfort with load-shedding, could turn into a profit and a much desired (green) export product. Remember the oil-boycott? Except for the directors and many people working at SASOL, I remember that it was the tax payers of South-Africa who lend the State some extra money to get patrol from coal. I am sure we can do it again. In fact, I think it is the only possible solution out of the current energy crisis. The sun and the wind are only pipedreams. They cannot supply the amount of power we really need.

Let’s go nuclear.

More info here: 3D-scale model of the HTMR-100 SMR nuclear complex (esi-africa.com)